The Marquesa Hotel was everything I wanted from an Old Town Key West hotel and quieter than I expected.
It’s tucked into a historic 1884 property on Fleming Street, close enough to walk to Duval Street, Mallory Square, and most of what makes Key West worth visiting, but removed enough that coming back to the property actually felt like a reset. Three separate courtyard pools instead of one big resort pool. An adults-only atmosphere that changes how the whole place feels. And Café Marquesa right downstairs, which ended up being my favorite meal of the entire trip.
It’s not a beachfront resort. There’s no big pool scene, no kids running around, no direct water views. That’s exactly the point and the tradeoff works really well if you want Old Town walkability with a quieter, more boutique feel.
The hotel earned a Michelin 2 Key designation in 2025, which made sense the moment I arrived. Polished without being stiff.
Full review with rooms, pools, what’s included in the amenity fee, and who I’d recommend it for | link in bio 🌴
Key lime pie is basically a required activity in Key West, so I turned it into a full taste test and tried 10 slices in one trip.🍋🟩
A few things I learned fast: I like mine tart. I want fresh homemade whipped cream, not meringue. And if the crust is thick and buttery, I am probably going to be thinking about that pie long after I leave Key West.
My overall winner was Café Marquesa silky smooth, almost perfectly balanced between tart and sweet, and it wasn’t even close. Most surprising stop: a rum distillery serving key lime rum pie with an orange-flavored topping and honestly the best meringue of the entire trip. Most overrated, in my opinion: Blue Heaven. I know that’s controversial. The filling was too sweet for me and the meringue overwhelmed everything else. Key lime pie preferences are personal enough that I still think you should try it yourself... you might completely disagree.
Full rankings with every stop and which ones I’d actually order again | link in bio
Some places you visit. Key West you embark on.
It doesn’t have a dress code, a quiet hour, or much patience for taking itself seriously. The streets are loud, the colors are aggressive, the chickens have no respect for personal space, and somehow all of it works together into something that feels completely its own.
This is not the trip for everyone. If you need a resort schedule, a pool with reserved chairs, and a plan for every hour, Key West is going to fight you on that. But if you show up willing to wander, eat well, watch the sunset from Mallory Square with a crowd of strangers who all somehow feel like regulars, and let the island move at its own pace... it will absolutely deliver.
Key West doesn’t try to be anything except exactly what it is. That’s the whole point.
Full guide linked in bio for anyone ready to embark. 🌴
#travelling #keywest #florida #keywestflorida #visitflorida
One day in Key West sounds like a lot until you realize Key West is very good at making one day feel like enough... if you plan it right.
The goal isn’t to hit every single attraction. It’s to experience the parts that make the island actually feel like Key West: Old Town, colorful streets, Whitehead Street, a photo at the Southernmost Point (get there early, the line is real), key lime pie, Mallory Square at sunset, and dinner somewhere that earns it. Café Marquesa was my favorite meal of the entire trip, and it has nothing to do with an ocean view. The food just stands on its own.
Swipe for the full day broken down by time, plus a shorter version if you’re visiting on a cruise. Full itinerary linked in bio. 🌴
A three-hour walking food tour through Old Town Key West that functioned as breakfast, lunch, and my new personality.
The Secret Food Tour hits five stops... and no, I’m not telling you where because discovering them is genuinely part of it. What I will tell you: the mutton snapper fish tacos with key lime mustard sauce were the dish I kept thinking about for days. There was also key lime pie involved at some point, which should surprise no one.
Our guide Deanna was excellent! She mixed local history and food stories in a way that felt like being shown around by someone who actually lives there rather than following a checklist. The group was small, the pacing was easy, and by the end I was completely full and slightly sad it was over.
Full review with everything you need to know before booking | link in bio 🌴
Follow @travelwithwendyplummer for Beautiful Beach Destinations, City Guides, Foodie Spots, and Luxury Hotel Recommendations.
