Lindey’s in Columbus Ohio is one of those classic restaurants that delivers on every level — from the atmosphere to the food to the neighborhood it’s nestled in. Located in the heart of German Village, Lindey’s has earned its reputation as a must-visit spot for both locals and visitors, and after dining there, it’s easy to see why.
If you’re planning a weekend in the city, my Weekend in Columbus, Ohio guide is a great place to start before reserving your table at Lindey’s.
My first tip: make reservations at least two to three weeks in advance, especially if you’re planning to go during peak dinner times.
We were able to walk in, but that was only because we showed up early, around 5 p.m. By 5:30 or 6 p.m., the dining room is in full swing, and you’re not likely to get a table without a reservation.
If you didn’t plan ahead, don’t worry. Lindey’s offers open seating at the bar and outside, which is a nice backup option when the weather cooperates.
Street parking is available throughout German Village, but spaces can be tight, especially during busy dinner hours. Give yourself a little extra time to park and walk to the restaurant.
Lindey’s feels polished and upscale without being uncomfortable or overly formal. Business casual is common, although you’ll see everything from jeans to dresses, so you don’t need to get overly dressed up.
The dining rooms have a classic, elegant look, while the patio is especially popular during warmer weather.
The German Village location also adds to the experience. You’re surrounded by brick streets, historic homes, mature trees, and some of the most recognizable places to visit in Columbus.
Let’s start with something simple that completely won me over: the bread.
Lindey’s has its fresh sourdough bread made in Grandview, and it is perfection. Paired with salty, rich butter, it’s a starter that immediately makes you realize you’re in for a memorable meal.
I found myself wondering whether I could buy a loaf to take home. It was that good.
For more great eats around town, check out my Ultimate Columbus Foodie Guide and Where to Eat in Columbus, Ohio.
One of the things I love about Lindey’s is that the menu changes seasonally, so there is usually something new and creative to try.
The portions are just right, which makes it easy to enjoy a full three-course meal without feeling completely overstuffed.
We’ve been lucky enough to dine here during Restaurant Week a few times, and every single dish has been a 10/10. Just to give you an idea of how thoughtful and inventive their food is, here’s what I ordered last time:
The asparagus salad included green and white asparagus, fresh herbs, preserved lemon, sauce gribiche, and pistachio crumble.
It was fresh, bright, and much more interesting than a basic dinner salad.
The six-ounce filet was served with buttermilk-chive whipped potatoes, haricots verts with thyme, roasted mushrooms, and steak hollandaise.
The filet was cooked beautifully, but the sides and sauces were just as carefully prepared. Nothing on the plate felt like an afterthought.
The Chicken Scarpiello included pan-seared Statler chicken breast, crispy smashed marble potatoes, Italian sausage, wood-grilled local oyster mushrooms, pickled peppers, and crushed tomato sauce.
It had a lot going on, but everything worked together. The pickled peppers and tomato sauce helped balance the richer chicken, sausage, and potatoes.
Save this for later on Pinterest so you don’t forget it.
Naturally, we ordered dessert. Leaving without trying dessert would have felt irresponsible after making it that far through the menu.
The vanilla panna cotta tartlet was served with roasted strawberry jam, fresh berries, and raspberry sorbet.
It was creamy, fruity, and light enough to finish after a full meal.
The Atlantic Beach Pie combined lemon curd, a Ritz cracker crust, and yuzu whipped cream.
The salty cracker crust was perfect with the tart lemon filling, and the yuzu whipped cream made it feel more creative than a traditional lemon pie.
Every dish was beautifully plated, packed with flavor, and balanced perfectly. Lindey’s is a rare restaurant where you could close your eyes, point to almost anything on the menu, and feel confident that it will be excellent.
For more fine-dining recommendations in the city, read my Agni Columbus Review: One of the Best Fine Dining Experiences in Columbus.
One of the best parts of eating at Lindey’s is that you’re already in the middle of German Village, one of the most charming neighborhoods in Columbus.
The brick-lined streets have a quaint, almost European feel that is completely different from the atmosphere in the Short North or downtown Columbus.
After dinner, take some time to walk around the neighborhood. Directly across the street from Lindey’s, there is a cute boutique.
Less than a quarter mile away is a historic mansion that once served as St. Mary’s School and Convent. Located at 673 Mohawk Street, the plaque outside explains that the property was part of St. Mary Catholic Church for more than a century and served the many German families moving into the area during the 1860s.
If you continue down the private drive and walk past the large church, you’ll find a charming candle and scent shop on the corner.
And across the street? The Book Loft—easily one of the most unique bookstores in the country.
You can find more German Village stops in The Perfect 24 Hours in Columbus, Ohio.
The Book Loft feels like stepping into a storybook.
You enter through a long walkway lined with plants, flowers, and water fountains, and it feels like you’ve wandered into a secret garden before you even reach the bookstore.
Then you start exploring the bookstore itself, which has—wait for it—32 rooms.
Yes, 32 rooms.
Each room is crammed with books, and you can wander from room to room as though you’re exploring a labyrinth. It’s easy to get lost, but that’s part of the fun.
Even if you’re not a big reader, walking through The Book Loft is an experience in itself. With more than 750,000 books tucked inside a collection of historic buildings, it isn’t something you’ll find in a typical shopping district.
A night at Lindey’s is more than just dinner. Between the perfectly baked sourdough bread, the creative seasonal menu, and the flawless execution of every dish, Lindey’s sets a high standard for fine dining in Columbus.
Pair dinner with a walk through German Village and a stop at The Book Loft, and you have the perfect evening out.
Just remember: book your reservation early, show up hungry, and leave time to wander after your meal.
If you end up booking anything for your trip, using my affiliate links helps support my blog at no extra cost to you. I spend a lot of time researching and writing these guides, so I really appreciate the support.
Compare Columbus hotel options through Booking.com.
Read Where to Stay in Columbus, Ohio for a breakdown of the best neighborhoods, hotel options, and which area makes the most sense for your trip.
Browse Columbus tours and activities through Viator.
Use Top 5 Things to Do in Columbus, Ohio to plan the rest of your sightseeing, including some of the city’s most popular neighborhoods, attractions, and local experiences.
German Village is best explored on foot, so bring comfortable shoes and a small phone and wallet crossbody strap for walking around after dinner.
A compact Danvek Mini Umbrella is also useful if rain is in the forecast.
Where to Eat in Columbus, Ohio — Find more of my favorite restaurants around the city, from casual breakfast spots to memorable dinner options.
Romantic Getaway in Columbus – 2-Day Itinerary — Plan a full couples’ weekend with restaurants, neighborhoods, and activities that work well for a special trip.
The Best Day Trips from Columbus, Ohio — Add another stop to your Ohio itinerary with easy day-trip ideas within driving distance of the city.
Haywood Smokehouse is the BBQ spot that ruins you for every other BBQ spot. Lean brisket so tender it doesn’t need the fat, fried pork ribs you won’t find anywhere else, and don’t sleep on the banana pudding for dessert.
Save this before your next Waynesville or Dillsboro trip 🍖🔥
Booked this Bryson City yurt for the ‘ber months and it’s already my top fall pick this year. 🍂
The Junaluska Yurt sleeps six but feels more like a stylish cabin than a yurt, two real queen bedrooms with actual doors, a full kitchen, and a private bathroom with a walk-in shower. Check-in is just a door code texted to your phone, no lobby, no waiting.
The real win is outside: wraparound porch, private fire pit, free firewood, a gas grill, and Smoky Mountain sunsets that stop you mid-sentence, picture all of that with October color on the ridgeline. Heads up, the last stretch in is a gravel road, so skip the low-profile rental, and there’s no restaurant onsite, you’re minutes from Bryson City, Dillsboro, and Sylva for dinner.
Two to three nights is the sweet spot. (We actually stayed in the dead of winter and it was still stunning, fall just takes it up a notch.) Full review linked in bio.
Italian food felt like the last thing I expected to find in the middle of the Appalachian Mountains... until I sat down at Ilda in Sylva.🍝
They call it Italian-Appalachian, and that’s not just a tagline. Homemade pasta, craft cocktails, local ingredients pulled straight from the mountains around it, this is the kind of meal that makes you forget you’re two hours from the nearest city. It’s cozy, it’s a little upscale, and it is not a walk-in kind of place, call ahead, because tables go fast on weekends.
It’s not cheap, and it’s not trying to be. But if you’re already making the trip out to Sylva, this is the one reservation worth planning your day around.
Full write-up, including what to order, link in bio.
Booked my fall cabin before September even started, and I’m not sorry about it. 🍂
These are the stays that make you actually want the cold to hurry up fireplaces, mountain views, the kind of porch you don’t leave. Not every one of these is going to fit every trip, but if a cozy fall getaway is on your radar, this is the roundup to start with.
One of my favorite travel seasons is almost here, and I have zero chill about it. 🍁✈️
There’s just something about fall trips cooler air, apple orchards, that first flannel of the season, food that actually makes sense with the weather again. I’m already mentally packing for it before September even starts.
If fall is your favorite time to travel too, tell me where you’re headed... I’m taking notes for the list.
Follow @travelwithwendyplummer for Beautiful Beach Destinations, City Guides, Foodie Spots, and Luxury Hotel Recommendations.
